[From Gary Gardner 
            and Payal Sampat, Mind Over Matter: Recasting the Role of Materials 
            in Our Lives, Worldwatch Paper 144, December 1998, page 26. Download 
            the report at WorldWatch] 
             
             
              Recent Proposals for Reductions 
            in Materials Use and For Increases in Materials Efficiency   
           | 
        
         
          | Group | 
          Year 
            Proposed | 
          Suggested 
            Target1 | 
          Actions or Proposed Actions | 
        
         
          | National Level | 
        
         
          | Austrian National Environment 
            Plan | 
          1996 | 
          10-fold | 
          To be achieved over the next decade. | 
        
         
          | Swedish Ecocycle Commission | 
          1997 | 
          10-fold | 
          Applies to both material and energy 
            efficiency; to be achieved over the next 25 to 50 years. | 
        
         
          | Dutch National Environment Plan | 
          1997 | 
          4-fold | 
          Based on a halving of resource 
            use and a doubling of wealth. | 
        
         
          | German Environment Ministry | 
          1998 | 
          2.5-fold | 
          Applies to non-renewable raw materials; 
            to be achieved by 2020. | 
        
         
          | International Level | 
        
         
          | Factor 10 Club | 
          1994 | 
          10-fold | 
          Declaration by 16 eminent scholars 
            from 10countries; reductions in materials flows to be achieved over 
            30-50 years in industrial nations. | 
        
         
          | OECD-Council at Ministerial Level | 
          1996-98 | 
          10-fold | 
          Is commissioning studies on the 
            potential for efficiency gains; views eco-efficiency as highly promising. | 
        
         
          | U.N. General Assembly | 
          1997 | 
          10-fold | 
          Calls for studies; gains to be 
            achieved over 2 to 3 decades. | 
        
         
          | World Business Council for Sustainable 
            Development and UNEP | 
          1997 | 
          10-fold | 
          Calls for improvements in eco-efficiency 
            worldwide. | 
        
         
          | 1For some 
            groups, target refers to an increase in materials efficiency; for 
            others, it refers to an overall reduction in material use. Increases 
            in efficiency may not result in reduced materials use, especially 
            over time. Source: See endnote 47 |